Back series GDP data: Former CEA Arvind Subramanian calls for review by experts to clear doubts

“As an economist, I think there are some puzzles [new back series GDP data], there are some issues that need to be explained,” Mr. Subramanian said.

Amid raging controversy over the revised economic growth numbers, former Chief Economic Adviser (CEA) Arvind Subramanian has called for an investigation by experts to clear doubts and build confidence while noting that the “puzzle” about the data needs to be explained.
 
He stressed that institutions that do not have technical expertise in calculating the GDP data should not be involved in the process, apparently referring to the Niti Aayog.

Mr. Subramanian, who criticised demonetisation in his new book titled 'Of Counsel: The Challenges of the Modi-Jaitley Economy', was, however, evasive when asked if he was consulted in the decision-making process on note ban.

“As an economist, I think there are some puzzles [new back series GDP data], there are some issues that need to be explained. Since there are things that need to be explained, we should, just to create confidence and eliminate any uncertainty or doubts, I think we should have experts who can investigate this thoroughly and give their answers,” Mr. Subramanian told PTI in an interview.

On the controversy over the Niti Aayog’s presence at the release of the GDP back series data by the Central Statistics Office (CSO) last month, he said that experts should have the main job of producing and explaining data.

“I think this [calculation of GDP] is a very technical task and technical experts should do the task, institutions that don’t have technical expertise should not be involved in this,” he said.

ALSO READ
 Arun Jaitley. File
Back series GDP data: Jaitley accuses Congress of opportunism

Recalibrating data of past years using 2011-12 as the base year instead of 2004-05, the CSO last month lowered the country’s economic growth rate during the previous Congress-led UPA’s regime.

Demonetisation
Asked whether he was consulted in the decision-making process on demonetisation, the former CEA said, “In the book, I said that this is not a Kiss and Tell memoir, that is for gossip columnists.”

Referring to criticism that he did not speak on demonetisation when he was working for the government and now he is raising the issue to sell his book, Mr. Subramanian said, “People will say whatever they say, right.”

“But through my new book, I was drawing attention to the puzzle, the big puzzle, 86% reduction in cash [after demonetisation] and yet the impact on the economy was much less,” he said.

The former CEA also wondered whether much less impact on the economy after demonetisation was due to current GDP calculation method.

“Is it [less impact on the economy after note ban] because we are not measuring GDP correctly, or is it because our economy is very resilient,” Mr. Subramanian who currently teaches at Harvard Kennedy School remarked.

ALSO READ
 Dissecting numbers: Congress leaders Shashi Tharoor, P. Chidambaram, Kapil Sibal and Manish Tewari at an interactive programme held in New Delhi on Friday.
If GDP is rising, where are the jobs?: Chidambaram

In the six quarters before demonetisation, growth averaged 8% and in the seven quarters after, it averaged about 6.8% [with a four-quarter window, the relevant numbers are 8.1% before and 6.2% after],” Mr. Subramanian wrote in the chapter “The Two Puzzles of Demonetisation — Political and Economic”.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on November 8, 2016, had announced demonetisation of ₹1,000 and ₹500 notes in a major assault on black money, fake currency and corruption.

Autonomy of RBI

On the recent spat between the government and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) over a host of issues, Mr. Subramanian opined that the autonomy of the RBI must be protected because the country will benefit by having strong institutions.

“But, I think there must also be cooperation, consultation and everything. Both have to happen,” he asserted.

On rising intolerance in the country, Mr. Subramanian said the experience in the world shows that the countries witness better economic development if there is more social peace.

Mr. Subramanian was the CEA in Finance Ministry from October 2014 to June 2018.