Does the GMAT give MBA applicants an edge over GRE takers?

25 per cent Of B-Schools say GMAT takers have advantage over GRE takers

Despite the increasing popularity of the GRE, the GMAT may be the best business school admissions test for MBA applicants, according to a Kaplan Test Prep study.

The report, based on a survey of 222 top business schools across the US and the UK, found that 25 per cent of the admissions officers said applicants who submit a GMAT score have an admissions advantage over those who submit a GRE score. Nikki Harle, Admissions Manager at EDHEC Business School said, “We do prefer GMAT.” She said the top European school prefers the GMAT over the GRE because it calculates eligibility for MBA scholarships based on GMAT results.

“If we get sent a GRE score we have to do a conversion online,” she added. EDHEC accepts both test results, but roughly 80 per cent of candidates submit GMAT scores, Nikki said.

Yet the GRE’s growing appeal is undeniable: 90 per cent of the schools surveyed by Kaplan allow applicants to submit a GRE score instead of a GMAT score, a 5 per cent increase on last year. In 2009, only one-quarter of business schools surveyed by Kaplan allowed students to submit a GRE score.

And more than 40 per cent of admissions officers reported an increase in the number of applicants submitting GRE scores year-over-year.

Although 74 per cent of admissions officers said they regarded the GMAT and GRE as equal, Brian Carlidge, executive director at Kaplan, advised applicants to “gather admissions intel” from their preferred schools before deciding which test to take.

“Some schools are reluctant to give both tests equal footing,” he said.

The result may be concerning for ETS (Educational Testing Service), the administrator of the GRE admissions exam. Jason Baran, ETS’s Public Relations Manager, rebutted the suggestion that business schools prefer the GMAT over the GRE.

He said, “Prospective MBA students who want to leverage the benefits of the GRE test will be glad to know that most of these schools are following Harvard Business School’s lead in weighting GRE scores equally with other business school admission tests.”

Ben Glover, Regional Managing Director for Europe and the Middle East at GMAC, owner of the GMAT, said “the GMAT may well be preferred” by business schools.

He added, “The GMAT is the only exclusively designed admissions test for business school. It would make sense for business schools to recognise that.”

In recent years, the GRE has come to be regarded as a viable alternative to the well-established GMAT.

Total test taker volume for the GRE last year was around 724,000, up 3 per cent on 2013. Comparatively, about 238,000 GMAT exams were taken in 2013, a fall of 16.8 per cent on the year before.

But the figures when compared can be misleading. The GRE covers graduate programs and the GMAT covers only business schools— total GRE volume is buoyed by other fields.