Afghanistan stability post US withdrawal

There is uncertainty about Afghanistan after the scheduled withdrawal of US troops but the region is not the same as it was in 1989 when the Soviet military pulled out and the presence of responsible regional powers like India and China might help to ensure stability in the embattled nation, say experts.

"No one, including me, knows what will happen, but we can outline parameters to make an assessment. (Coalition) combat troops will leave, the Afghan army will take over security aided by US and foreign advisors - a few thousands, the government will keep the cities and main roads secure, the US and Afghanistan governments will try to resume the peace process - now stalled - with the Taliban," said Barnett Rubin, who has served as an advisor to Richard Holbrooke, US special envoy to Af-Pak, and was involved in trying to begin negotiations with the Taliban.

"What will be the balance of power? Who will collapse? All this remains to be seen," he said at a session "Dispensable Nation: Afghanistan After the US Withdrawal" on the third day Sunday of the Jaipur Literature Festival 2014.

"It can be argued the changes in Afghanistan are both irreversible... and unsustainable," he quipped.

Rubin, however, contended that the view that must be taken should be free from dichotomies about what will happen.

"It's not the same Afghanistan any longer, it's not the same Pakistan, it's not even the same region," he said.

He noted that regional powers like India and China were taking responsibilities, including of security, and the latter is telling Pakistan that it doesn't want a Taliban government in Kabul.

"That will not accomplish all that is wanted but will certainly check Pakistan's behaviour," he said.

"It is not like 1989 (when the Soviet troops withdrew)," he stressed.

Mark Mazzetti, national security correspondent of the New York Times and author of a book about the US operation for targeted killings of terrorists, said it was disheartening to see there was more concern in Jaipur about the situation in Afghanistan than in Washington D.C., where there is a "degree of fatigue" over what has been the US' longest war.

"There are meetings, talks but it (Afghanistan) is not the highest priority of the Obama government. There are doubts about (Afghan President Hamid) Karzai. It's not a rush to the exit yet, but it is certainly a quick walk," he said.

Mazzetti said there was a marked difference of opinion between the primary US stakeholders - the military, the CIA, the State Department and the White House - about what would happen and what should be done.

He also said he believed that China and India - and Pakistan as well - would continue to play a key role.

Intervening here, Rubin said there was convergence on Beijing and Washington's views on the situation in areas west of China.

"The Chinese attitude is that Pakistan is not a very reliable ally in south Asia... it is seeing cooperation with the US in Afghanistan," he said.

Journalist Ben Anderson, who has accompanied coalition forces in counter-insurgency operations in Afghanistan, said the role of Afghan security forces was not seen positively by the people in the south Pakhtun belt, and he could from his personal experience say their activities made the Taliban "look like the good guys".

He foresaw a civil war at least in south Afghanistan to remove the "government proxies".

The speakers also dwelt on the ethnic issue, which created a vicious struggle for power and patronage in a poor country.

They also agreed Pakistan has to be brought in for a meaningful settlement.

The problem is, the experts said, is the divergence in approaches - the US wants the matter to be solved between Afghans, the Karzai government want to hold peace talks with the Taliban, and the Taliban wants the peace process only after the US leaves.

"Everyone wants peace... only their concept of peace is the other side surrendering," said Rubin.. Models sold like hot cakes. The flagship model Galaxy S4 comes packed with a 1.6 GHz octa core Exynos 5 processor and costs Rs 41,500. The S4 also has special features like S-Voice (like other Galaxy flagships), Smart Stay eye tracking and TV Out to name a few.

The Lumia 520 is a budget phone from Nokia family and it grabbed the second spot in Google Trends. The Nokia Lumia 520 smartphone is powered by Windows Phone 8 and a 1GHz dual core processor. The gasget comes with exclusive digital lenses and a touchscreen that even works with long nails or gloves.

Micromax, the biggest threat for Samsung in India, has come up with the Canvas series. The Micromax Canvas is a super sleek phone with a 12.5 cm multi-touch screen with a 16.8 million color display. The phone comes with a 1GHZ processor and a HD camera of 8 megapixel.

Samsung Galaxy Grand comes with a deluxe large display for better viewing and visuals. Powered by Android 4.1.2 (Jelly Bean), the latest version of the world’s most popular smartphone operating system, Grand was trending fourth in Google.

The Micromax Canvas is a 12.7cms High Definition phone with 8 MP camera. The canvas is powered by a 1GB DDR2 RAM and a 1.2 GHz Quad Core Processor along with the Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean making it respond really fast.

The new Sony Xperia Z1 smartphone's camera functions are further supported by a large image sensor and dedicated apps that allow users to stream video directly onto their Facebook page, store images online and search for information about whatever their viewfinder is pointing at.

The Lumia series is a solid piece of hardware with colourful replaceable shells. The handset's AMOLED screen with ClearBlack tech does full justice to Windows Phone UI, which is a mixture of deep blacks and vibrant hues. The Windows Phone 8 OS is not only refreshingly different, but is also very well optimized.

Micromax is now looking to challenge the mighty Samsung’s dominance in India with its mid-range phone Canvas 4. Priced at Rs 18,000 the Canvas 4 looks like any other Android handset except for the aluminium frame, which also works as antenna.

The LG Nexus 4 runs the latest Android 4.2 Jelly Bean, and being a Nexus device, it will be the first one to receive future OS updates. The Nexus 4 features a 4.7" True IPS Plus screen with 1280x768 pixels.

Almost a year after its launch, Samsung Galaxy S III is still one of the best Android phones around. The phone is powered by Exynos 4412 chipset that boasts of a quad-core 1.4 GHz Cortex-A9 processor, and Mali-400MP GPU. The 4.7" HD AMOLED screen offers vibrant colours and great contrast.

The features of Samsung Galaxy III include an 8 megapixel camera, Wi-Fi, A-GPS, Bluetooth 4.0, 1 GB RAM, 16 GB internal storage, microSD card slot, and 2100 mAh battery. It comes with Android Jelly Bean 4.1. Street price: Rs 25,000